Sierra Club logo
Backtrack
Sierra Main
In This Section
  September/October 1996 Features:
Newt's Game
A Chosen Few
Does He Deserve Your Vote?
Adios Amigos
Natural Allies
 
  Departments:
Letters
Ways & Means
Food for Thought
Whereabouts
Hearth & Home
Way to Go
Priorities
Sierra Club Bulletin
In Print
Last Words
 

Sierra Magazine
Newt's Game:
Time to Play the Game of REVOLUTION!


RULES OF THE GAME

It's an outrage! America's once-proud corporations--the giants who drill her oil, mine her gold, chop her forests, build her malls, and grow her beefsteak--are being forced to operate under (gulp) legal constraints!

Twenty-five years of protecting the public's air, water, lands, and health--it has to stop! But industry can't stop it alone. No, all the polluter PAC money in the world can't turn back the clock on environmental protection--it takes revolutionaries like Newt Gingrich . . . Dick Armey . . . Tom DeLay . . . "Citizen" Bob Dole. And they need soldiers to reach the finish line!

Are you ready? Then get set to grab those campaign checks, and go straight to the floor of Congress with your sponsors' pet bills. But remember: there's only so much cash to go around.

So start moving--forward, into the past. Time to play REVOLUTION! Taking Capitol Hill was only the first step . . .

(But first . . . )

As you wend your way through the game of REVOLUTION, you'll pass through a number of fantasy- lands, where the voices of the Gingrichite faithful can be heard, baying for an end to environmental protections. Welcome to

REPUBLICAN THEME PARKS: LAW-OF-THE-JUNGLE LAND

House Resources Chair Don Young, regretting his 1973 vote for the Endangered Species Act: "We envisioned trying to protect, you know, pigeons and things like that. We never thought about mussels and ferns and flowers and all these subspecies of squirrels and birds."

In November 1995, Young and a member of his committee, Richard Pombo (R-Calif.), introduced H.R. 2275, which would have effectively gutted the ESA. The bill was so radical that Speaker Gingrich prevented it from coming to a vote on the floor of the House.

The Senate's endangered species bill was authored, ostensibly, by Slade Gorton (R-Wash.). But a leaked memo from a Gorton aide revealed its real source: "The [industry] coalitions delivered your ESA bill to me on Friday. It is important that we have a better than adequate understanding of the bill prior to introduction. . . . The bill takes some getting used to."

Under a measure by Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison (R-Texas), the Fish and Wildlife Service was barred from adding any species to its "endangered" list for over a year.

LAND OF LIVING DANGEROUSLY

The House not only moved to slash the Environmental Protection Agency's enforcement budget by one- third, but attached 17 EPA riders to critical budget bills--including provisions to bar new groundwater safeguards and to allow cancer-causing pesticides in our food.

A medley of "takings," "cost-benefit," "risk-assessment," and "regulatory reform" measures offered by Republicans in both houses had one thing in common: they added costs and red tape that would have made it difficult for the federal government to pass new environmental laws, or to enforce existing ones.

The House passed a version of the Clean Water Act that would have lowered treatment standards for thousands of pollutants and opened roughly half of the nation's wetlands to development.

CANDOR LAND

Tom DeLay (R-Texas), majority whip, on the perks of power:

"We're in charge. We don't have to compromise with the Senate. We don't have to compromise with the President. We're only going to fund the programs we like."

Dana Rohrabacher (R-Calif.), one of California's two "surfing congressmen," defending his vote to trash the Clean Water Act:

"Clean water is good enough. We don't have to have pristine water."

Sonny Bono (R-Calif.), freshman problem-solver, on endangered species:

"Give them all a designated area and then blow it up."

Newt Gingrich (R-Ga.), House speaker,on where the revolution went wrong:

"We clearly are strategically out of position on the environment. We approached it the wrong way with the wrong language."

Linda DiVall, Republican pollster:

"Our party is out of sync with mainstream American opinion."

Don Young (R-Alaska), chair of the House Resources Committee, on where he went wrong:

"What I should have done is repealed the whole [Endangered Species] Act. . . . Right quick. Before anybody realized what had happened."

FRONTIER LAND

Led by Utah Congressman James Hansen, House Republicans offered a bill to close some national parks and historic sites. Unlike most such GOP proposals, which bogged down in the Senate or were vetoed by the White House, this one was too extreme even for the lower chamber.

The all-Republican Alaska delegation, having failed in previous Congresses to open the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil-and-gas exploration, tried to sneak in via the federal budget process. Their drilling provision would have allowed the oil industry into the 1.5-million-acre coastal plain of the refuge, the springtime calving ground for the 160,000-strong Porcupine caribou herd and the ecological heart of the refuge.

Hansen and fellow Utah Republicans introduced legislation to open most of the state's wilderness to development. Ignoring a "citizens' proposal" to protect 5.7 million acres of southern Utah's redrock country, the delegation offered to designate just 1.8 million acres as "wilderness"--replete with dams, roads, power lines, and a gas pipeline--and permanently bar protection for the rest.

In the War on the Environment's one significant victory, Congress passed the "logging without laws" rider, which suspended environmental laws, giving the timber industry free rein in national forests. The provision led to massive clearcutting of publicly held forests, including old growth in the Pacific Northwest.

THE LAND OF MILK AND MONEY

From 1991 to 1994, the 166 cosponsors of a bill to gut the Safe Drinking Water Act received nearly $10 million in campaign contributions, or an average of $60,000 each, from industries wanting to weaken federal drinking-water standards.

In 1994, Newt Gingrich raked in $78,000 from 267 "dirty water" PACs, more than anyone else in Congress. Bud Shuster (R-Pa.)--the nominal author of the polluter-penned "Dirty Water Act"--got $44,600 from the same group.

In 1995, House majority whip Tom DeLay accepted $75,000 in campaign contributions from corporate PACS intent on weakening the Clean Air Act. DeLay promptly introduced eight separate pieces of legislation to that end, including a bill to repeal all the improvements made to the act in 1990.

From January through July of 1995, polluter PACs contributed $5.6 million to members of Congress. Of the top 20 recipients, 19 were Republicans, with DeLay and Gingrich topping the list at $93,000 and $90,000 respectively.


REVOLUTION!--THE GAME

The town is yours. No one's actually read the Contract With America. Make your own rules. George Will, Sam Donaldson, Cokie Roberts all like your "grit." Advance one square.

Disguise anti-environment bills as anti-Washington. Advance 2 squares.

Lunch with mining lobbyist. Enviros hold a press conference. Ignore it--everyone else does. Editorial slams your "War on the Environment." An aberration, but still. Proceed with caution.

Pass your first industry-sponsored bill in the House. Advance one square.

NBC runs 12-part series on struggling dirt farmer unable to feed, clothe 14 children. Blames Endangered Species Act. Children agree. Advance 2 squares.

Enviros discover "dirt farmer" owns half of California. Story buried near funeral notices. Relax and roll again.

Most of Contract sails through House. Roll again. Enviro radio spots identify you as a friend to polluters. Miss a turn.

Bills bog down in Senate. Miss a turn.

Introduce bill to gut Clean Water Act. Charge ahead one square.

Enviros dub your bill "Dirty Water Act." Press picks up theme. Go back 3 squares.

Citizens flood your office with angry calls and letters. Miss 2 turns.

Slow news day. Several reporters finally read Contract. Miss a turn.

Dinner with timber lobbyist. Constituents learn Contract ravages the environment. Go back 2 squares.

Contract declared DOA in Senate. Miss 2 turns.

Introduce budget rider to raze public forests. President vetoes, then signs. Advance 6 squares.

Lunch with oil lobbyist. Head of key committee, unclear on the concept, offers bill to endanger species. Miss two turns due to embarrassment.

Newt hits on new strategy: Load anti-enviro agenda onto budget bills! Cheer up and roll again.

President vetoes budget bills. Go back 3 squares.

Shut down government. Get blamed by voters. Shut down government again. Go back to drawing board.

Newt hits on newest strategy: Act green until election day. Miss one turn trying.

Election Day! TIME FOR THE BIG SPIN...

You win Congress and the White House!
Polluters rule!

You win Congress, lose White House!
Play game over.

You lose Congress, win the White House!
(Not a chance--spin again.)

You lose Congress and the White House!
Environment wins!


Up to Top


Sierra Magazine home | Contact Us Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights | Terms and Conditions of Use
 
Sierra Club® and "Explore, enjoy and protect the planet"®are registered trademarks of the Sierra Club. © Sierra Club 2019.
The Sierra Club Seal is a registered copyright, service mark, and trademark of the Sierra Club.