Sierra Club logo
Backtrack
Sierra Main
In This Section

  May/June 2001 Issue
 
Features: 100 Years of Sierra Club Outings:
Happy Trails
280 Boots and 14,000 Feet
Mountain Memories
First on Top
Learning to Walk in the Wilderness
 
Energy Features:
Snake Oil for Fossil Fools
A Modest Proposal to Stop Global Warming
 
  Departments:
Letters
Inside Sierra
Ways & Means
Lay of the Land
Hearth & Home
Profile
Bulletin: News for Members
Mixed Media
 
Back Issues
Information
Submission Guidelines
Advertising Guidelines
Contact Us
Sierra Magazine

LAY OF THE LAND

Printer-friendly format

Some Bright Ideas Are Better Left Buried

by Marilyn Berlin Snell

Almost everyone agrees that recycling is a good idea. Even the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has jumped on the bandwagon. Unfortunately, what the NRC wants to recycle glows in the dark.

According to NRC documents, the federal agency is in the process of conducting a "literature search" (not a scientific study) on the pros and cons of recycling and reselling contaminated soil from decommissioned nuclear-weapons and -power plants. The surreal document, called "Human Interaction with Reused Soil" details how more than 2 million articles were culled down to 56, which were then reviewed for clues as to whether recycling radioactive soil is a bright idea. One article that made the cut is titled "Methodology to Estimate the Amount and Particle Size of Soil Ingested by Children: Implications for Exposure at Waste Sites." Nowhere in the NRC document, however, does the reader discover why the idea of recycling contaminated soil is being entertained in the first place.

"It's a semantic shell game," says Diane D'Arrigo of the Nuclear Information and Resource Service. "For economic and liability reasons, the NRC is trying to reclassify contaminated soil so they can disperse it."

Instead of being buried or in some other way permanently separated from "human interaction," the soil from these plants could conceivably end up being sold to homeowners, brick makers, and landscapers, among other unsuspecting consumers. As far-fetched as the idea sounds, the NRC has already managed to reclassify and sell contaminated metals from decommissioned plants--a move that was strongly resisted by organizations like the Steel Manufacturers Association, which uses recycled metals in the manufacturing process.

NRC public-affairs officer Mindi Landau defends her agency's recycling policy, arguing that people are already exposed to naturally occurring background radiation. "Everything has radioactivity," she says. "[The NRC] just has to establish what levels are acceptable."

But John Gofman, the physicist who isolated the first milligram of plutonium from irradiated uranium in 1942, finds the NRC's stand ludicrous. "By any reasonable standard of biomedical proof," says Gofman, "there is no safe dose [of radiation]; just one decaying radioactive atom can produce permanent mutation in a cell's genetic molecules." The United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation and the British Radiological Society, among others, agree with Gofman.

Landau is unmoved by such claims. "A lot of scientists also say that a small dose of radioactivity is good for you," she responds. "I'm not saying that that's true, but you'll find just as many scientists who disagree with [Gofman's] position. We're not going to react to emotions. People are afraid of radioactivity; they're afraid of anything nuclear. It's just like a built-in emotion. And we're not going to react to that."

p>The NRC's public-comment period has expired, but there is no statute of limitations on public opposition. To find out what you can do, visit the Nuclear Information and Resource Service or call (202) 328-0002.


Up to Top


Sierra Magazine home | Contact Us Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights | Terms and Conditions of Use
 
Sierra Club® and "Explore, enjoy and protect the planet"®are registered trademarks of the Sierra Club. © Sierra Club 2019.
The Sierra Club Seal is a registered copyright, service mark, and trademark of the Sierra Club.

Confidentially Yours | Wise-Use Movement | Nuclear Regulatory Commission News | Federal Loans Spawn Sprawl | Shell sets its sights on Bangladesh | Bottled Water | Bold Strokes | Updates